
The Colorado Court of Appeals issued four opinions on Thursday, November 19. Read the case summary and full opinion, below.
The People of the State of Colorado, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. Rudy Levi Hurtado, Defendant-Appellant. 2026 COA 83. A division of the court of appeals considers, for the first time, whether a statute’s use of a defendant’s prior convictions as an element of an offense, as opposed to a sentence-enhancing factor, violates the Equal Protection Clauses of the United States and Colorado Constitutions. The division concludes that the power to make such designations lies solely with the legislature and that a defendant’s equal protection rights are not violated when the legislature opts to treat distinct offenses differently. Read the opinion.
In re the Marriage of Lindsay Shaw Thornton n/k/a Lindsay Shaw, Appellant and Cross-Appellee, and Murray Alexander Thornton, Appellee and Cross-Appellant. 2026 COA 84. In this dissolution of marriage proceeding, a division of the court of appeals addresses two matters of first impression. First, the division assesses the nondischargeability of certain debts under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(15). The division concludes that the wife’s bankruptcy discharge did not preclude the trial court from imposing sanctions for her litigation misconduct pursuant to its inherent authority to sanction such conduct. Second, the division interprets C.R.C.P. 53, which authorizes the trial court to appoint special masters. The division follows federal case law and the advisory committee’s note to Fed. R. Civ. P. 53 and holds that C.R.C.P. 53(f)(1) does not entitle a party who contests the special master’s findings to a hearing. The trial court satisfies the rule by taking written submissions from the parties and may, but need not, hear live testimony. Read the opinion.
Friends of Animals, River Runners for Wilderness, and Living Rivers, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission and Division of Parks and Wildlife, Defendants-Appellees. 2026 COA 85. A division of the court of appeals considers whether a state agency violates the rulemaking provisions of the State Administrative Procedure Act (APA), §§ 24-4-101 to -204, C.R.S. 2026, when it invites public comment on proposed legislative rules using a communication method not mentioned in the official notice of rulemaking but then fails to include those comments in the rulemaking record or consider them when promulgating the final rules. The division concludes that it does. The division also concludes that the violations in this case prevented the agency from substantially complying with the APA, requiring that the challenged rules be set aside as invalid. Read the opinion. Read the opinion.
The People of the State of Colorado, Petitioner-Appellee, In the Interest of Dean Perry Babb, Respondent-Appellant. 2026 COA 86. A division of the court of appeals considers whether a request to administer medication to a patient involuntarily through a nasogastric tube presents a distinct question, requiring its own evidentiary support, from the question whether the medication may be administered at all. The division concludes that a court may not approve such a request absent a showing by clear and convincing evidence that administration of the medication through a nasogastric tube satisfies the third element of People v. Medina, 705 P.2d 961, 974 (Colo. 1985): “If less intrusive methods are available to effectively redress these concerns, then clearly the court should deny the motion for nonconsensual treatment.” Thus, a record supporting the involuntary administration of a particular medication is not, alone, sufficient to warrant administration of that medication through a nasogastric tube.
In this case, the People did not establish that a nasogastric tube was necessary to administer medication to the patient. For this reason, the division vacates the authorization to involuntarily administer medication by nasogastric tube. Read the opinion.
